UK fails in bid to keep demand to Apple secret
- Tribunal rejects government’s secrecy over reported UK demand that Apple grant access to users’ encrypted data, handing victory to Apple and privacy groups.
- Government defends access request as necessary for public safety; Apple had suspended its Advanced Data Protection feature for UK users earlier.
- Civil liberties groups call ruling a victory for privacy, spotlighting clash between encryption’s safety for users and law enforcement access.
A British tribunal ruled Thursday that the UK government should not keep secret a demand made to Apple, reportedly that the US tech giant grant it access to users’ encrypted data.
“We reject the… contention that it would be damaging to national security” to keep the reported demand secret, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal said in its written judgment, handing victory to Apple and privacy groups which brought separate legal challenges.
The Financial Times previously reported that Apple had filed legal challenges against London’s attempt to gain the access — under a so-called “backdoor” order.
The UK government meanwhile had not confirmed such reports.
However responding to Thursday’s ruling, a government spokesperson said in a statement:
“The right to privacy is crucial but it should not come at the expense of the safety of the British public.”
They added: “Apple has been helping the police and intelligence agencies pursue criminals and bring them to justice for several years, in accordance with the law.
“This Technical Capability Notice simply requires that they maintain the ability to do so.”
Freedom-of-information lobby group Liberty, which along with Privacy International, brought their own legal challenge against the government, called the ruling “a victory for privacy rights”.
Apple had yet to respond to AFP’s request for comment.
– Encrypted data –
The UK’s government reported demand had sparked tensions between London and Washington, ultimately prompting the UK to drop its request for access to American citizens’ data, then-US intelligence chief Tulsi Gabbard said on X in August 2025.
London had instead reportedly asked Apple for access to its British users’ encrypted data — the focus of the company’s most recent legal challenge.
Many tech platforms pride themselves on being able to guarantee privacy through encryption of messages and other content, and providing access to law enforcement has long been seen as off-limits.
Apple stopped offering its most advanced encryption feature — known as Advanced Data Protection — for British users in February 2025.
ADP ensures that only account holders can view content such as photos and documents stored in the cloud through end-to-end encryption.
Police officials worldwide say encryption can shield criminals, terrorists and pornographers from prosecution even when authorities have a legal warrant for an investigation.
But civil rights and privacy advocates, along with many cybersecurity professionals, praise data encryption as a way to protect against wrongful snooping by authorities as well as hackers.
“The public deserve to know when the government’s actions undermine their privacy and safety, and we welcome the Tribunal’s decision, which will shine more light on these secretive powers,” Director of Liberty, Akiko Hart, said following Thursday’s judgment.
