‘Broadview 6’ prosecutors say they won’t take the Fifth as potentially explosive hearing looms
Three federal prosecutors who handled the disastrous “Broadview Six” case will not invoke their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination when the time comes to testify, their lawyers assured a judge Monday.
However, it’s unclear how much they’ll be able to say once they’re under oath. That’s the upshot of a 20-minute status hearing that drew Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, the Justice Department’s third-highest ranking official, to a Chicago courtroom.
It’s also unclear what U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros will do.
It’s remarkable that federal prosecutors in Chicago even had to consider taking the Fifth. But U.S. District Judge April Perry has ordered them to testify Dec. 2 in a hearing with little precedent that could lead to sanctions, or even a finding of criminal contempt.
Perry used Monday’s status hearing to prepare for the potential testimony.
In another sign of how the tables have turned, the judge spent much of Monday’s hearing speaking with a new group of lawyers — representing the prosecutors who nearly took the “Broadview Six” case to trial.
Meanwhile, some of the former defendants watched as spectators from the courtroom gallery.
The case began as a conspiracy prosecution against six Operation Midway Blitz protesters. It collapsed in spectacular fashion in May amid allegations of prosecutor misconduct. Now, Perry has ordered Boutros to testify along with Assistant U.S. Attorneys William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez.
The judge has said her “sole focus, at this point, is on lack of candor, concealment of material facts, or other misconduct that occurred before me.” She’s specifically raised questions about claims prosecutors made to her while the case played out.
But in a motion filed late Sunday, Woodward said the four prosecutors have been “instructed” to assert legal privileges, which could prevent them from testifying.
He argued that “there is plainly no need for anyone but the U.S. attorney to provide information,” and he suggested Perry leave the matter to the executive branch — meaning President Donald Trump and Attorney General Todd Blanche.
Woodward also floated the possibility that he’ll seek relief from the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
As a result, Monday’s courtroom conversation revolved mostly around the Justice Department’s attempt to assert legal privileges. During the hearing, attorneys for Hogan, Skiba and Almendarez told Perry their clients don’t plan to invoke their Fifth Amendment right.
Hogan attorney Shelly Kulwin said his client “doesn’t intend to assert any privileges.”
Perry assured the lawyers she won’t ask questions “that would call for a privileged answer.” Still, she acknowledged the prosecutors might want to offer explanations that cross that boundary.
So she gave them until Friday to submit a written version of any such testimony for her review. She said she’d give the feds until Nov. 25 to explain why privilege should prevent the testimony from going forward.
Woodward told the judge he was concerned about privileged information being handed over to her ahead of the hearing. He said the Justice Department “may have an issue” with what he described as the judge “wearing dual hats.”
But Perry said it’s not unusual for a judge to ignore inadmissible evidence that’s come before her.
And it’s not clear who would decide whether the testimony is privileged, if not Perry.
